| School | State | Tuition | Students | International Students | SAT | Type and Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Epiphany Of Our Lord School | -- | 299 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-8 | |
| Grace Prep High School | -- | 65 | -- | -- | Grades 9-12 | |
| Greene Street Friends School | -- | 276 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-8 | |
| Hill Top Preparatory School | $39,190 | 72 | -- | -- | Grades 5-12 | |
| The Pen Ryn School | $11,200 | 250 | 2% | -- | Nursery-8 | |
| The Quaker School At Horsham | $34,850 | 66 | -- | -- | Grades Kindergarten-9 | |
| Resurrection Of Our Lord School | -- | 584 | -- | -- | Grades Kindergarten-9 | |
| St. Anastasia Elementary School | -- | 646 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-8 | |
| St. Bridget Elementary School | -- | 182 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-8 | |
| St. Eleanor Elementary School | -- | 489 | -- | -- | Grades Kindergarten-9 | |
| St. Ignatius Elementary School | -- | 268 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-8 | |
| St. John Bosco School | -- | 165 | -- | -- | Grades Kindergarten-9 | |
| St. Joseph's Preparatory School | $16,600 | 976 | 3% | -- | Grades 9-12 | |
| Ss Simon & Jude School | -- | 453 | -- | -- | Grades Kindergarten-8 | |
| Stern Hebrew High School | -- | 95 | -- | -- | Grades 9-12 | |
| Shoreland Lutheran High School | $2,000 | 309 | -- | -- | Grades 9-12 | |
| Wisconsin Lutheran High School | -- | 924 | 7.1% | 1177 | 9-12 | |
| Archbishop Hoban High School | $13,950 | 860 | -- | 1240 | Grades 9-12 | |
| Bishop Ready High School | $10,300 | 440 | -- | 1320 | Grades 9-12 | |
| Bishop Rosecrans High School | $7,150 | 148 | -- | -- | 9-12 |