| School | State | Tuition | Students | International Students | SAT | Type and Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Our Lady Of Destiny School | $3,950 | 193 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-8 | |
| St. Edmund Parish School | -- | 163 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-8 | |
| St. Gall Elementary School | $3,500 | 272 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-8 | |
| St. Hyacinth Basilica School | $4,400 | 163 | -- | -- | Grades Nursery/Preschool-8 | |
| St. Laurence High School | $12,800 | 1034 | -- | -- | 9-12 | |
| St. Patrick High School | $10,500 | 1015 | -- | -- | Grades 9-12 | |
| St. Pauls Lutheran School | -- | 139 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-8 | |
| St. Tarcissus Elementary School | -- | 425 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-8 | |
| South Side Baptist School | -- | 100 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-12 | |
| Timothy Christian High School | $15,200 | 452 | 1.1% | 1203 | 9-12 | |
| Tri-state Christian School | $21,000 | 170 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten-12 | |
| The David Gregory School | -- | 29 | -- | -- | n/a | |
| The Kings Christian School | $8,900 | 292 | -- | -- | Grades Prekindergarten - 12 | |
| Mesivta Pe'er Hatorah | -- | 43 | -- | -- | Grades 9-12 | |
| Newark Boys Chorus School | $2,700 | 79 | -- | -- | Grades 4-8 | |
| Paul Vi High School | -- | 1192 | -- | -- | Grades 9-12 | |
| Seton Hall Preparatory School | $24,200 | 975 | 1.5% | 1280 | 9-12 | |
| The Wardlaw-Hartridge School | $52,600 | 441 | 7% | 1310 | PreK-12 | |
| Bryn Athyn Church School | -- | 299 | -- | -- | Grades Kindergarten-8 | |
| Davidson School, Elwyn Inc. | -- | 305 | -- | -- | Grades Nursery/Preschool-12 |